Celebrating 17 Years of Excellence: Castello's Pizza Earns Four Honors in the 2026 Central Florida Favorites Awards

Castello's Pizza has earned a remarkable achievement that reflects the loyalty and passion of its customers. In the 2026 Central Florida Favorites by the Orlando Sentinel, Castello's Pizza was honored as a 4-time winner across multiple categories. This recognition highlights the restaurant’s commitment to quality food and genuine hospitality since 2009. Let’s explore what makes Castello's Pizza a beloved choice in Central Florida and how these awards celebrate the community’s support.

Castello's Pizza winning multiple awards for appetizers, pizza, salad, and catering

A Legacy of Quality and Hospitality

Since opening its doors in 2009, Castello's Pizza has focused on serving fresh, high-quality food paired with warm, genuine hospitality. This approach has built a strong connection with the local community in Clermont and Windermere. The restaurant’s mission is simple but powerful: provide an exceptional dining experience that feels like home.

The 2026 Central Florida Favorites awards reflect this mission. Castello's Pizza won:

• Gold for Appetizers

• Silver for Salad

• Bronze for Pizza

• Bronze for Catering

  
  

These awards cover a wide range of offerings, showing that Castello's excels not only in pizza but also in appetizers, salads, and catering services.

What Makes Castello's Pizza Appetizers Stand Out to be Recognized as Central Florida Favorites

Winning the gold award for appetizers is no small feat. Castello's offers a variety of starters that appeal to different tastes, from crispy wings to flavorful garlic knots. Customers often praise the freshness of ingredients and the perfect balance of seasoning.

Some popular appetizers include:

• Buffalo Jumbo Wings with just the right amount of spice and tenderness

• Mozzarella Sticks with a crispy coating and gooey cheese inside

• Alligator Tail Breaded alligator meat, fried to perfection and served with sweet & tangy sauce

  
  

These dishes set the tone for a satisfying meal and are perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Fresh and Flavorful Salads

The silver award for salad highlights Castello's dedication to fresh ingredients and creative combinations. Their salads are not just side dishes but a key part of the menu that appeals to health-conscious diners and those looking for lighter options.

Examples of fan favorites:

• Caesar Salad with crisp romaine, creamy dressing, and crunchy croutons

• Greek Salad featuring olives, feta cheese, and fresh vegetables

• House Salad with a mix of greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and a choice of dressings

  
  

Each salad is prepared with care, ensuring freshness and flavor in every bite.

Bronze Recognition for Pizza Excellence

Pizza is the heart of Castello's, and earning a bronze award in this category confirms their strong reputation. Their pizzas are known for a perfect crust, fresh toppings, and balanced flavors.

Key features include:

• Hand-tossed dough made fresh daily

• High-quality cheeses and meats

• A variety of classic and specialty pizzas to suit all tastes

  
  

Whether you prefer a simple Margherita or a loaded meat lover’s pizza, Castello's delivers consistent quality that keeps customers coming back.

Catering That Brings People Together

Castello's bronze award for catering shows their ability to serve larger groups with the same attention to detail as in the restaurant. Catering options include a range of pizzas, appetizers, salads, and sides that make family gatherings, office parties, and special events memorable.

Catering highlights:

• Flexible menu options to fit different event sizes

• Timely delivery and setup

• Food that stays fresh and delicious even when served buffet-style

  
  

Many customers trust Castello's to handle important occasions, knowing the food will impress guests.

Castello's Pizza Earns Four Honors - The Role of Community Support

These awards belong to every customer who has dined in, ordered takeout, or trusted Castello's for their family events. The votes from the community reflect genuine appreciation for the restaurant’s food and service.

Castello's team expresses deep gratitude for this support. It fuels their passion to keep improving and delivering the best experience possible.

Locations and Accessibility

Castello's Pizza serves Central Florida from two convenient locations:

• Clermont

• Windermere

  
  

Both locations offer dine-in, takeout, and catering services, making it easy for customers to enjoy their favorite dishes wherever they are.

Looking Ahead: Continuing the Tradition

Winning four awards in the Central Florida Favorites is a milestone that inspires Castello's Pizza to keep raising the bar. The team plans to maintain their focus on fresh ingredients, friendly service, and community engagement.

Customers can expect:

• New menu items inspired by feedback

• Special promotions and events

• Continued commitment to quality and hospitality

  
  

Castello's Pizza aims to remain a top choice for Central Florida residents for many years to come.

---

Thank you to everyone who has made Castello's Pizza a Central Florida favorite. Your support turns every meal into a celebration. Visit Castello's Pizza in Clermont or Windermere, or order online at www.castellospizza.com to experience award-winning food and service for yourself.

Celebrate with Us and Taste the Difference: Castello's Pizza Earns Four Honors Thanks to Our Passion, Dedication, and Community Support