Google Reviews About Castello’s Pizza in Clermont & Windermere

What Our Google Reviews Say About Castello’s Pizza in Clermont & Windermere – Orlando

When people search “best pizza in Clermont” or “Italian restaurant near Windermere and Dr. Phillips,” they don’t just look at menus—they look at reviews. And we’re incredibly grateful for the hundreds of guests who’ve shared their experience with Castello’s Pizza on Google.

According to Trustindex, which aggregates our Google reviews, Castello’s Pizza holds a 4.4 out of 5 rating with 495 total reviews, coming directly from Google.TrustindexThat’s not just a number to us—that’s the voice of our community in Clermont, Windermere, and the greater West Orlando area.

A Strong Local Reputation in Clermont

Our main location at 4290 S Hwy 27, Clermont, FL 34711 is listed as the HQ on the Trustindex page, and it’s clear from the reviews that locals consider us a go-to spot for pizza and Italian comfort food.Trustindex

Guests in Clermont often mention:

• “Best pizza in town”–style comments praising the flavor and crust

• Love for our calzones, specialty pies, and Brazilian-inspired options

• Consistently friendly service and clean, welcoming dining room

Families from nearby neighborhoods along Hwy 27 and surrounding communities like Minneola, Groveland, and Four Corners talk about Castello’s as their local pizza place—some even sharing stories of birthday parties, family get-togethers, and “first pizza night after moving to the area.”

Loved by Locals, Travelers & New Neighbors

Reading through the Google reviews, you’ll see a mix of:

• Long-time Clermont locals calling us their favorite locally owned pizza spot

• New residents saying we were the first pizza place they tried after moving here—and that we didn’t disappoint

• Visitors who discover us while exploring Central Florida and are surprised to find authentic, handcrafted pizza away from the tourist traps

Many reviews highlight details like:

• Perfectly baked crust – crispy on the outside, soft on the inside

• Noticeable quality of the sauce and cheese

• Fresh toppings and generous portions

• A cozy, casual vibe that feels like a neighborhood restaurant, not a chain

These aren’t our words—they’re patterns that come up again and again in the Google feedback aggregated on Trustindex .Trustindex

355 Five-Star Reviews (and We Read Every One)

On the Trustindex page, you can see the breakdown of our Google reviews: out of 495 total, 355 are 5-star ratings, with the majority of the rest being 4-star .Trustindex

That tells us a few important things:

• People across Clermont, Windermere, Gotha, Ocoee, and Orlando aren’t just trying us once—they’re enjoying the experience enough to go online and leave a positive review.

• Our focus on fresh dough, homemade sauce, and quality ingredients is noticed and appreciated.

• Service matters. Many guests mention our friendly, attentive staff just as much as the food itself.

We don’t take that lightly. Every review—good, mixed, or critical—helps us serve our community better.

We Reply to Reviews Because Your Voice Matters

Another detail you’ll see on the Trustindex report: Castello’s Pizza has replied to 100% of reviews listed there.

Why?

Because:

• If you took the time to share your experience, we want you to know we’re listening.

• When there’s praise, we’re genuinely grateful.

• When there’s constructive feedback, we want to learn from it and improve.

For us, Google reviews are not just “ratings”—they’re a conversation between Castello’s and the community we’ve been serving since 2009.

Why Google Reviews Matter for Local Search (SEO)

If you’ve ever typed “pizza near me Clermont”, “Italian restaurant near Hwy 27 Clermont”, or “pizza Windermere near Dr. Phillips” into Google, you’ve seen how reviews show up right next to local businesses.

Strong Google reviews help:

• Boost visibility when people search for pizza and Italian food in Clermont, Windermere, Bay Hill, Dr. Phillips, and Metrowest

• Build trust with new guests comparing options in the area

• Show real-world proof that our food and service are worth trying

Our Trustindex profile, powered exclusively by Google reviews, helps showcase that social proof in one place—so anyone browsing our website can instantly see what other guests are saying.Trustindex

Serving Clermont, Windermere & West Orlando With Pride

Between our Clermont location on S Hwy 27 and our Windermere/Orlando location on Conroy Windermere Rd, our goal is the same:

• Fresh, handcrafted dough

• House-made tomato sauce

• Quality cheese and toppings

• A welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere

The reviews reflect that mission—from locals calling us their “favorite neighborhood pizza place” to new guests who say they’ll “definitely be back.”

Have You Left Your Google Review Yet?

If you’ve visited Castello’s Pizza in Clermont or Windermere – Orlando, we’d love to hear from you:

• Share what you ordered

• Tell us what you loved

• Let us know how we can make your next visit even better

Your Google review doesn’t just help us—it helps neighbors, families, and visitors looking for authentic, local pizza in Clermont and West Orlando make a better choice.

Thank you for every star, every comment, and every shared experience.You’re the reason “Castello’s Pizza reviews” looks the way it does today—and we’ll keep working to make it even better, one pizza at a time.