Looking for the Best Pizza in Windermere? Castello’s Pizza Has the Answer!

Castellos Pizza
Aug 16
3 min read

Updated: Aug 17

Serving Windermere, Gotha, Ocoee & West Orlando – Including Bay Hill, Dr. Phillips & Metrowest

When the craving hits for pizza that’s handcrafted, full of flavor, and served in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere — locals in Windermere and the surrounding neighborhoods know there’s one place to go: Castello’s Pizza - The Best Pizza in Windermere

We’ve been proudly serving the community since 2009 with authentic Italian flavors, made-from-scratch dough, and ingredients you can taste in every bite.

1. Where can I order pizza in Windermere?

Order directly from Castello’s Pizza Windermere online at www.castellospizza.com, or call 407-876-0021 for pickup or delivery.

2. Pizza places with a family-friendly atmosphere in Windermere?

Our Windermere location is cozy, clean, and perfect for families. We’ve got spacious seating and a welcoming team that makes everyone feel at home — whether it’s a weeknight dinner or a weekend outing.

3. Where can I buy traditional Italian pizza near Windermere?

At Castello’s, we bring true Italian flavor to your table using hand-tossed dough, Grande® mozzarella, and classic recipes. Whether you're in Windermere, Ocoee, or Dr. Phillips, you’re never far from the real deal.

4. Where can I get a large pizza for a family gathering in Windermere?

Our extra-large pizzas are perfect for family meals or group events. You can even build your own or choose one of our specialty pies designed to satisfy everyone.

5. (Repeated) Pizza places with family-friendly atmosphere in Windermere?

Still Castello’s! From the cozy setting to the attentive service, we’re the go-to spot for families across Windermere, Gotha, and West Orlando.

6. Where to find catering services for parties in Windermere?

We offer full-service Italian catering for birthdays, school events, office parties, and more — complete with delivery and setup across the area, including Bay Hill and Metrowest.

7. Who delivers family-style pizza in Windermere?

We do! Our in-house delivery team brings hot, fresh family-sized meals to homes across Windermere, Gotha, Ocoee, and nearby neighborhoods.

8. How to order pizza from Castello’s Pizza in Windermere?

Ordering is easy:

Visit www.castellospizza.com
Call us at 407-876-0021
Or find us on delivery apps like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub

9. Where to get Italian catering services in Windermere?

Castello’s Pizza offers Italian-style catering with pasta trays, salad bowls, garlic knots, and pizza platters — all made fresh and delivered to your door.

10. Where can I order pizza online in Windermere?

Head to our website to browse the full menu and place your online order: www.castellospizza.com

11. Best pizza restaurant near Windermere, Florida?

Locals from Dr. Phillips to Gotha consistently rate Castello’s as one of the top pizza spots in the area. Why? Because we blend authentic flavor, quality ingredients, and neighborhood hospitality.

12. Who offers pizza delivery in Windermere, Florida?

Castello’s Pizza offers fast, reliable delivery across Windermere and surrounding areas. Whether you’re in Metrowest or Bay Hill, we’ve got you covered.

13. What are popular pizza toppings in Windermere?

Our most requested toppings include:

Classic pepperoni
Sausage and mushroom
Fresh basil and tomato
You can also build your own masterpiece!

14. Where to order gluten-free pizza in Windermere?

We offer gluten-free crust options for many of our pizzas. Just ask when ordering and we’ll take care of the rest.

15. How is pizza traditionally made in Italy?

Italian pizza starts with hand-stretched dough, minimal but quality toppings, and high-temperature baking — exactly how we do it at Castello’s, honoring time-tested traditions.

16. Best place to get Italian food in Windermere, Florida?

From creamy pastas to garlic knots, calzones to fresh salads — Castello’s is more than just pizza. We’re your local Italian kitchen.

17. Best catering for events in Windermere, Florida?

We’re trusted by businesses, schools, and families across Windermere and West Orlando to deliver delicious, stress-free catering that’s made to impress.

18. Where to find vegetarian pizza options in Windermere?

Try our Margherita, Supreme, or create your own veggie-loaded pie with ingredients like spinach, peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms.

📍 Visit Us: 8947 Conroy Windermere Rd, Orlando, FL (serving Windermere & surrounding areas)

📞 Call Now: 407-876-0021

🌐 Order Online: www.castellospizza.com

📸 Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/castellos_pizzeria/

📸 Follow us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/

At Castello’s Pizza Windermere, we’re proud to serve more than just food — we serve tradition, comfort, and community. Come taste the difference today